An order was filed in the United States District Court
for the District of Arizona today by United States District
Judge David G. Campbell in favor of the National Park
Service (NPS) on a lawsuit titled River Runners for
Wilderness, et al., vs Stephen P. Martin, et al.
A coalition of four wilderness advocacy groups had brought
suit against the NPS in March 2006, under the Administrative
Procedures Act, challenging the Parks 2006 Colorado
River Management Plan, which among other things, permits
the continued use of motorized rafts and support equipment
in Grand Canyon National Park.
A hearing was held on October 26, 2007 in the United
States District Court for the District of Arizona in
which Judge Campbell heard oral arguments on the case.
We are pleased with the ruling and that Judge
Campbell recognized the agencys discretion and
authority to make difficult and at times controversial
decisions, stated Steve Martin, Grand Canyon National
Park Superintendent. We look forward to working
with all user groups, including wilderness advocates,
as we continue to implement the Parks Colorado
River Management Plan.
National Park Service News
Release
Record of Decision Signed on Revision
of Colorado River Management Plan for Grand Canyon
National Park
March 23, 2006
Grand Canyon, AZ – The National Park Service
(NPS) announced in the Federal Register today the
availability of the “Record of Decision”
(ROD) for the revision of Grand Canyon National Park’s
Colorado River Management Plan (CRMP).
The ROD, signed by Intermountain Regional Director
Mike Snyder, is the latest step of a multi-year effort
to complete the revision of the CRMP - last revised
in 1989. The CRMP is a visitor use management plan
which specifies actions to conserve park resources
and the visitor experience, while enhancing recreational
opportunities. The life of the plan is intended to
be at least 10 years, and it will also establish management
goals and objectives for a longer timeframe.
Grand Canyon National Park began this latest process
to revise the CRMP in 2002. The Hualapai Tribe, which
shares a common boundary with the National Park Service
(NPS) along 108 miles of the Colorado River, was a
cooperating agency in the preparation of the Environmental
Impact Statement, prepared under the provisions of
the National Environmental Policy Act. Meetings were
held throughout the country to identify the kinds
of issues the public thought the NPS should consider
in developing a long-term management plan. Major issues
and concerns regarding resource protection, visitor
experience and services raised during the public process
included:
For purposes of the Environmental Impact Statement,
the Colorado River in the park was divided into two
geographic sections that recognize the different management
zones on the river, and a specific set of alternatives
were developed for each section. The first section
of river is from Lees Ferry (River Mile [RM] 0) to
Diamond Creek (RM 226). The second section is from
Diamond Creek (RM 226) to Lake Mead (RM 277). In developing
the plan, NPS considered eight management scenarios
for the first section of river and five management
scenarios for the second section of river. Each scenario
was analyzed for its impacts on the environment and
for how well it complies with federal laws, regulations,
policies, previous planning decisions, the park’s
vision, and other mandates for the management of recreational
use on the Colorado River through Grand Canyon National
Park. The ROD adopts the NPS preferred alternative
for each section of the river.
For the first section of river from Lees Ferry to
Diamond Creek, the ROD calls for a mixed motor/no-motor
alternative with 5.5 months of mixed use occurring
from April 1 through September 15, and 6.5 months
of non-motorized use from September 16 through March
31. The decision also calls for smaller group sizes
and fewer daily allowable launches except during winter
months, and allows for a moderate increase in estimated
yearly passenger totals. Passenger exchanges at Whitmore
will be allowed only during the mixed-use period,
April 1 through September 15, with a time-of-day restriction,
and in the non-motorized season only for those trips
launching during the mixed-use period.
The ROD calls for use limits and a redistribution
of Hualapai River Runner (HRR) operations for the
section of river from Diamond Creek to Lake Mead.
Peak daily use for commercial day trips launching
from Diamond Creek will be comparable to current conditions,
with smaller maximum group sizes, while commercial
overnight trips could increase from a current average
of three launches per month to up to three launches
per day. The number of pontoon boat passengers in
the Quartermaster area will be capped at 480 per day,
but could increase to 600 per day based on favorable
performance reviews and resource monitoring data.
No jet boat tours will be allowed, and upriver travel
will continue to be allowed up to River Mile 240.
A No Action/Split Allocation system will continue
to allocate use between the commercial and noncommercial
sectors in a ratio that is reflected in the preferred
alternative and will remain the same for the life
of the plan.
A “hybrid” weighted lottery system for
trip leaders will be implemented as the noncommercial
permit system for Lees Ferry to Diamond Creek river
trips. Each year a single lottery will take place
and result in the initial awarding of the following
year’s noncommercial launch opportunities. Chances
in the lottery will vary depending on whether or not
applicants had been on a river trip recently. A three-stage
expedited transition system will be instituted for
those people currently on the noncommercial waitlist
to transition to the hybrid-weighted lottery system.
The NPS will develop an implementation and monitoring
plan that outlines how it will implement the provisions
specified in the ROD. The final CRMP, including the
implementation and monitoring plan, will be published
and made available to all interested parties.
A complete copy of the ROD and associated information
will be available on the park’s Web site at
www.nps.gov/grca/crmp.
Written requests can be sent to CRMP Team at P.O.
Box 129, Grand Canyon, AZ 86023.
-NPS-
Grand
Canyon River Groups Achieve Historic Breakthrough
Settlement and Offer Joint Proposal on Key Colorado
River Management Issues
January
25, 2005
GROUPS FORMERLY AT ODDS SETTLE DIFFERENCES
Flagstaff, AZ – Today, leading
Grand Canyon boater groups that represent both professionally-outfitted
and self-outfitted recreational users of the Colorado
River in Grand Canyon National Park announced an historic
agreement to work together to resolve long-standing
river management controversies at the Grand Canyon.
The
coalition of participating groups, including the Grand
Canyon River Outfitters Association, the Grand Canyon
Private Boaters Association, American Whitewater and
the Grand Canyon River Runners Association, has filed
a set of joint management recommendations with the
National Park Service regarding how best to revise
and update the Colorado River Management Plan.
View the groups' joint
recommendations here.
"A
lot of people have worked very hard for many years
to achieve this historic breakthrough,” said
Richard Martin of the Grand Canyon Private Boaters
Association. “This is a major achievement that
we hope will help bring about real and lasting solutions
to some very difficult problems that Grand Canyon
river lovers on all sides have wrestled with for years."
The
groups' core recommendations are for a small number
of important modifications of the National Park Service
river management proposal currently open for public
review and comment. The groups are building on the
NPS proposal, not proposing an entirely new plan or
concept. The recommendations include equal annual
allocations of commercial and non-commercial use,
support for the park's proposal to continue with an
appropriate type and level of motorized use, seasonal
adjustments that would result in fewer river trips
happening at one time, and improvements to the non-commercial
river trip permitting system.
"This
effort succeeded because people on all sides wanted
to move past endless controversy and divisiveness
to find real solutions to real problems. It's time
to heal and reunite the Grand Canyon boating community,"
said Jason Robertson of American Whitewater. "To
do that, each of the groups has been willing to compromise
and look at issues in new ways. There's still a long
way to go, but we're excited because we think we're
off to a good start."
The
groups' joint recommendations filed with the NPS state
in part: "The joint recommendations are the product
of what we regard as a major and historic achievement,
the coming together of Grand Canyon river user groups
that traditionally have been embroiled in deep conflict
regarding core Colorado River management issues. We
have worked very hard to move beyond past differences.
Our united purposes are to constructively participate
in and support the NPS in its effort to advance Grand
Canyon river management and, most importantly, to
meaningfully resolve major outstanding controversies.
Our shared focus is on problem solving and the implementation
of sound, responsible and lasting solutions to outstanding
issues."
"We
hope very much that the NPS will take a good hard
look at our proposal," said Pam Whitney of the
Grand Canyon River Runners Association. "We've
worked hard to respond not only to the issues but
to all of the NPS laws and policies that govern how
the river in Grand Canyon National Park is managed.
We’ve taken these matters very seriously, and
we believe we’ve come up with a very responsible
set of recommendations."
The groups' joint Colorado River management recommendations
document is available on each of the participating
groups' websites. The website addresses for each are
listed below.
The
Grand Canyon River Outfitters Association
(www.gcroa.org)
is a non profit trade association whose membership
consists of the sixteen independent river-running
concessionaires who make available to the public professionally-outfitted
and guided Grand Canyon whitewater rafting trips,
while working in partnership with the NPS to help
conserve and protect the resources of the Park. Each
year, the Association’s member companies assist
roughly 19,000 people experience the Grand Canyon
by river.
The
Grand Canyon Private Boaters Association
(www.gcpba.org)
is a non-profit public interest group formed in 1996.
Its purpose is to represent and advocate for the interests
of recreational river runners in regards to management
issues surrounding the Grand Canyon. More than one
thousand river runners have joined the all-volunteer
organization, which played a key role in NPS decisions
to resume river management planning after the effort
was first cancelled in 2000.
American
Whitewater (www.americanwhitewater.org)
is a non-profit public interest group that works to
conserve and restore America’s whitewater resources
and to enhance opportunities to use and enjoy them
safely. American Whitewater represents nearly 8,000
members worldwide and an additional 80,000 boaters
through its 115 local or regional affiliate canoe
and kayak clubs. Many of its members have visited
or seek to visit the Colorado River within the Park
and are currently on the non-commercial permit “waiting-list.”
The
Grand Canyon River Runners Association (www.gcriverrunners.org)
is a non-profit public interest group committed to
the protection of the Colorado River corridor within
the Grand Canyon in an unimpaired condition while
preserving public access to the Grand Canyon river
experience for those who rely on professional river
services. Because both are necessary to appropriately
respond to the public’s diverse needs, this
all-volunteer organization with 1,800 members supports
both motorized and non-motorized Colorado River trip
opportunities.